ANALYSIS OF METHODICAL DEFECTS IN PHD AND DOCTORAL THESIS ON ECONOMICS
https://doi.org/10.17853/1994-5639-2016-7-177-190
Abstract
The aim of the article is to consider the most typical defects
which can be found in PhD and doctoral dissertations on economic sciences. The research is based on a work experience of the author as the member of dissertation council, the reviewer and the opponent of dissertation works.
Methods. The methods of the analysis, comparison, and generalization are used while researching the problem.
Results and scientific novelty. The miscalculations and errors in master’s and doctoral dissertations on economics which have methodical nature and not depend on a specific subject of work are disclosed and systematized. In particular, the following questions concerning the process of work are studied out on specific examples: work with information sources, Internet resources; options of correct and incorrect use o tools of information technologies; applied problems of results of scientific research, etc.
Practical significance of the publication consists, firstly, in recommendations of the author concerning leveling and elimination of common defects of dissertation works and scientific articles; secondly, in the proposal of the general and methodical plan for introduction of training standards in a postgraduate study.
About the Author
R. D. Gutgarts
Irkutsk National Research Technical University, Irkutsk (RF)
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Doctor of Economics, Professor, Department of Automated Systems
References
1. Veselkov F. S., Dobrusina M. E. Dissertacija jekonomista: opyt shkoly molodogo uchenogo «Student – aspirant». [Thesis of the economist: experience of school of the young scientist «The student – the graduate student»]. Tomsk: Tomskij gosudarstvennyj universitet. [Tomsk State University], 2010. (In Russian)
2. Gutgarts R. D. «Reefs» by preparation of the master’s thesis on economic specialties in full-time postgraduate study. Innovacionnoe razvitie jekonomiki Rossii: rol’ universitetov: III mezhdunarodnaja konferencija, MGU im. M. V. Lomonosova, 21–24 aprelja 2010 g.: sbornik statej: T. 1. [Innovative Development of Economy of Russia: Role of Universities: 3rd International Conference, Lomonosov Moscow State University, 21–24 April, 2010. Collection of articles. V. 1]. Ed. by V. P. Kolesov, L. A. Tutov. Rybinsk: Publishing House Ofis 2000, 2010. P. 492–499. (In Russian)
3. Gutgarts R. D. Features of dissertation scientific research. Vysshee obrazovanie segodnja. [Higher Education Today]. 2011. № 11. P. 65–69. (In Russian)
4. Gutgarts R. D. Features of the initial stage of preparation of the candidate thesis. Vysshee obrazovanie segodnja. [Higher Education Today]. 2013. № 2. P. 66–70. (In Russian)
5. Bug And. «A dissertation trap» on the way to creation of innovative economy. Voprosy jekonomiki. [Economy Questions]. 2011. № 9. P. 129–133. (In Russian)
6. Zaguzov N. System of preparation and certification scientific and research and educational personnel in Russia. Alma Mater. Vestnik vysshej shkoly. [Alma Mater. Bulletin of the Higher School]. 2007. № 3. P. 24–35. (In Russian)
7. Kozhukhar V. M. Praktikum po osnovam nauchnyh issledovanij. [Workshop on bases of scientific research]. Moscow: Associacija stroitel’nyh vuzov. [Association of Construction Higher Education Institutions]. 2008. (In Russian)
8. Kolesnikova N. I. Ot konspekta k dissertacii: uchebnoe posobie po razvitiju na-vykov pis’mennoj rechi. [From the abstract to the thesis: the education guidance on development of skills of a written language]. 3rd edition. Moscow: Publishing House Flinta, 2006. (In Russian)
9. Korikov A. M., Mitsel A. A. Thesis and academic degree: methodical benefit for job seekers. [Dissertacija i uchenaja stepen’: metodicheskoe posobie dlja soiskatelej]. Tomsk: Tomskij gosudarstvennyj universitet sistem upravlenija i radiojelektroniki. [Tomsk State University of Management Systems and Radio Electronics]. 2007. (In Russian)
10. Kuzin F. A. Kandidatskaja dissertacija: metodika napisanija, pravila oformle-nija i porjadok zashhity. [Master’s thesis: technique of writing, rule of registration and order of protection]. 10th edition Moscow: Publishing House Axis-89, 2008. (In Russian)
11. Kuznetsov I. N. Dissertacionnye raboty: metodika podgotovki i oformlenija. [Dissertation works: technique of preparation and registration]. 4th edition. Moscow: Publishing House Dashkov and Kº, 2009. (In Russian)
12. Kuznetsov I. N. Nauchnoe issledovanie: metodika provedenija i oformlenie. [Scientific research: technique of carrying out and registration]. Moscow: Publishing House Dashkov and Co, 2004. (In Russian)
13. Novikov A. M. Doktorskaja dissertacija. [Doctoral dissertation]. 3rd edition. Moscow: Publishing House Egves, 2003. (In Russian)
14. Rayzberg B. A. Dissertacija i uchenaja stepen’. [Thesis and academic degree]. 10th edition. Moscow: Publishing House INFRA-M, 2011. (In Russian)
15. Rayzberg B. A. Napisanie i zashhita dissertacij. [Writing and theses defence]. Moscow: Publishing House Marosejka, 2011. (In Russian)
16. Reznik S. D. Kak zashhitit’ svoju dissertaciju. [How to defend the dissertation]. 3rd edition. Moscow: Publishing House INFRA-M, 2011. (In Russian)
17. Ryzhikov Ju. I. Rabota nad dissertaciej po tehnicheskim naukam. [Work on the thesis on technical sciences]. 2nd edition. St.- Petersburg: Publishing House BHV – St.-Petersburg, 2007. (In Russian)
18. Shklyar M. F. Osnovy nauchnyh issledovanij. [Bases of scientific research]. 2nd edition. Moscow: Publishing House Dashkov and Co, 2008. (In Russian)
19. Shchadov M. I. Metodika formirovanija dissertacionnogo issledovanija po spe-cial’nosti 08.00.05 – Jekonomika i upravlenie narodnym hozjajstvom. [A technique of forming of a dissertation research on specialty 08.00.05 – Economy and management of the national economy]. Irkutsk: IrGTU, 2007. (In Russian)
20. Pomoshh’ v napisanii dissertacij, nauchnyh statej, avtoreferatov. [Help in writing of theses, scientific articles, abstracts]. Available at: http://www.xn—80aaa4a0ajicdpl.xn—p1ai/dissertacii. (In Russian)
Review
For citations:
Gutgarts R.D. ANALYSIS OF METHODICAL DEFECTS IN PHD AND DOCTORAL THESIS ON ECONOMICS. The Education and science journal. 2016;(7):177-190. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.17853/1994-5639-2016-7-177-190
Views:
1352
Email this article 