THEORY OF INTEGRAL INDIVIDUALITY BY V. S. MERLIN: HISTORY AND NOWADAYS
https://doi.org/10.17853/1994-5639-2017-2-145-160
Abstract
The study is devoted to overview and analysis of V. S. Merlin’ theory of integral individuality.
The aim of the study is to reveal a system’s background of the theory of integral individuality; to designate its current issues and to put new tasks of its further advancement.
Methodology and research methods. Problematic and comparative analyses are used. A systematization of the main assumptions of the theory by V. S. Merlin shows that it is based on a general systemic approach and current ideas about integration.
Results. It is demonstrated that the system-based approach provides a multi-focus perspective to view the integral individuality. Mostly, the following system ideas are embedded in V. S. Merlin’s theory. They are the concepts of structural levels, teleology, and polymorphism. With respect to the theory of integral individuality, a human is shown as a big system. It consists of a hierarchical set not included in each other, but relatively autonomous operative multilevel subsystems. They link one to another in a polymorphic multi-valued (many-tomany) way. The main features of integral individuality are seen as the hierarchical arrangement and levels, integration and differentiation, teleology and causality, flexibility of polymorphic links (between levels) and rigidity of causal links (within levels). In spite of its maturity, this theory can be put in a further progress. This perspective has been elaborated based on three key ideas – multi-quality, commonality, and isomerism.
Scientific novelty. The routes of the phenomenon of integral individuality are uncovered. Its main properties are described: a systemic version of integrity, hierarchy, and polymorphism. Some topical problems are highlighted within the theory of integral individuality. Next tasks can be set to further develop the theory of integral individuality. They focus on shift from the systemic viewpoint to a multi-systemic outline, to combine integrity and commonality, to provide an isomerism coming from the polymorphic framework.
Practical significance. The materials and thesis stressed in this article can be useful for researchers studying holistic conceptions of human. The theory of integral individuality can guide investigations designated to test Merlin’s assumptions under various conditions.
About the Authors
B. A. VyatkinRussian Federation
Corresponding Member of the Russian Academy of Education, Doctor of Psychological Sciences, Professor, Scientific Adviser of Psychological Institute
Perm (Russia)
L. Ya. Dorfman
Russian Federation
Doctor of Psychological Sciences, Professor, Head of Department for Psychology and Pedagogy
Perm (Russia)
References
1. Viytkin B. A. Integralnaiy individualnost cheloveka i ee razvitie. [Integrated identity of the person and its development]. Moscow: Institut psihologii RAN. [Institute of Psychology of the Russian Academy of Sciences]. 1999. (In Russian)
2. Viytkin B. A. Lekcii po psihologiy integralnoi individualnosti. [Lectures on psychology of integrated identity]. Moscow; Voronezh: Moskovskij psihologo-social’nyj institute. [Moscow physocological-social institute]; Modek, 2007. (In Russian)
3. Viytkin B. A., Shukin M. R. Development of the doctrine about integrated identity: problems, results, prospects. Psihologicheskij gurnal. [Psychological Journal]. 1997. V. 18. № 3. P. 126–141. (In Russian)
4. Dorfman L. Ya. Methodological analysis of the theory of integrated identity of V. S. Merlin. Metodologiy i istoriy psihologii. [Methodology and History of Psychology]. 2008. V. 3. № 3. P. 106–121. (In Russian)
5. Klimov E. A. О trude i lichnosti V. S. Merlina (shtrihi k harakteristike). About work and V. S. Merlin’s identity (strokes to the characteristic). V. S. Merlin. Psihologiy individualnosti. [Merlin V. S. Psikhologiya of identity]. Moscow: Institut prakticheskoi psihologii. [Institute of Practical Psychology]; Voronezh: Modek, 1996. P. 7–19. (In Russian)
6. Dorfman L. Y. Volf Merlin’s theory of integral individuality. I. Lubek, R. van Hezewijk, G. Pheterson, Ch. Tolman (Eds.). Trends and Issues in Theoretical Psychology. New York: Springer publishing co., 1995. Р. 158–163. (Translated from English)
7. Merlin V. S. Ocherk integralnogo issledovaniy individualnosti. [Sketch of an integrated research of identity]. Moscow: Publishing House Pedogogika, 1986. (In Russian)
8. Kuzmin V. P. Historical prerequisites and gnoseological bases of system approach. Psihologicheskij gurnal. [Psychological Journal]. 1982. № 3. P. 3–14. (In Russian)
9. Tutuhin V. S. Problema svyzey i otnosheniy v materialisticheskoi dialektike. [A problem of communications and the relations in materialistic dialectics]. Moscow: Publishing House Nauka, 1990. (In Russian)
10. Urmancev U. A. Obshay teoriy system. [General theory of systems]. Sistema. Simmetrija. Garmonija. [System. Symmetry. Harmony]. Ed. by V. S. Tjuhtin, Ju. A. Urmancev. Moscow: Publishing House Mysl’, 1988. (In Russian)
11. Vernadskiy N. N. About polymorphism as the general property of matter. Uchenye zapisky Moskovskogo universiteta, otdelenie estestvenno-istoricheskih nauk. [Scientific Notes of the Moscow University, Department of Natural-Historical Sciences]. 1892. № 9. P. 1–18. (In Russian)
12. Viytkin B. A., Shukin M. R. Psihologija stilej cheloveka. [Psychology of styles of the person]. Moscow; Perm: Publishing House Knizhnyj mir, 2013. (In Russian)
13. Viytkin B. A. Polisistemnoe issledovanie individual’nosti cheloveka. [Polysystem research of identity of the person]. Moscow: Publishing House PER SE, 2005. (In Russian)
14. Vjatkin B. A., Dorfman L. Ja., Shhukin M. R. Psihologija integral’noj individu-al’nosti: permskaja shkola. [Psychology of integrated identity: Perm school]. Moscow: Publishing House Smysl, 2011. (In Russian)
15. Rubinshtein S. L. Bytie i soznanie. [Life and consciousness]. Chelovek i mir. [Person and world]. St.-Petersburg: Publishing House Piter, 2003. (In Russian)
16. Dorfman L. Y. Causal pluralism and holism in the concept of meta-individual worl. Psihologija: zhurnal Vysshej shkoly jekonomiki. [Psychology. Journal of Higher School of Economics]. 2016. V. 13. № 1. P. 98–136. (In Russian)
17. Viytkin B. A., Dorfman L. Y. New horizons of the theory of integrated identity of V. S. Merlin. XXXI Merlinskie chtenija: Teorija, metodologija i praktika inte-gral’nogo issledovanija individual’nosti v sovremennom chelovekoznanii. [31st Merlinsky readings: The theory, methodology and practice of an integral research of identity in the modern anthropology]. Perm: Permskij gosudarstvennyj gumanitarno-pedagogicheskij universitet. [Perm State Humanitarian and Pedagogical University]. 2016а. P. 11–17. (In Russian)
18. Viytkin B. A., Dorfman L. Y. Printsip of polymorphism in the theory of integrated identity: Modern representations and prospects of its development. XXXI Merlinskie chtenija: Teorija, metodologija i praktika inte-gral’nogo issledovanija individual’nosti v sovremennom chelovekoznanii. [31st Merlinsky readings: The theory, methodology and practice of an integral research of identity in the modern anthropology]. Perm: Permskij gosudarstvennyj gumanitarno-pedagogicheskij universitet. [Perm State Humanitarian and Pedagogical University]. 2016b. P. 109–113. (In Russian)
19. Dorfman L. Y. Jemocii v iskusstve: teoreticheskie podhody i jempiricheskie is-sledovanija. [Emotions in art: theoretical approaches and empirical researches]. Moscow: Publishing House Smysl, 1997. (In Russian)
20. Dorfman L. Y., Lydov V. N. Metaindividual model of discipline (on material of a research of cadets of military higher education institution of the Ministry of Internal Affairs). Vestnik Juzhno-Ural’skogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Serija: Psihologija. [Bulletin of the Southern Ural State University. Series: Psychology]. 2015. V. 8. № 1. P. 17–28. (In Russian)
Review
For citations:
Vyatkin B.A., Dorfman L.Ya. THEORY OF INTEGRAL INDIVIDUALITY BY V. S. MERLIN: HISTORY AND NOWADAYS. The Education and science journal. 2017;(2):145-160. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.17853/1994-5639-2017-2-145-160