The convergence of the concepts of academic and inclusive excellence at research universities

Introduction. In the 21st century, there is an active involvement of universities in inclusive processes; however, against the backdrop of increasing diversity, new types of inequality arise in higher education. The processes of transformation of organisational cultures in universities and their research agenda under the influence of inclusion need to be studied.

The aim of the present research was to analyse the convergence of concepts of academic and inclusive excellence in foreign universities of the world level, the impact of convergence on their missions, the values expressed in official strategies, the research agenda and the infrastructure of scientific collaborations.

Methodology and research methods. The authors conducted a content analysis of three strategies of world-class University associations (the Association of American Colleges and Universities, the Association of Universities in Canada, the League of European Research Universities), nine strategies for the development of universities in the USA and Canada, the European Union, and Australia. A scientometric analysis of Web of Science metadata was performed using the VOSViewer software.

Results and scientific novelty. The current research confirms the convergence of values of academic excellence and inclusion in research universities. It is revealed that the concept of inclusive excellence of the university is an enriched version of its academic excellence and denotes a set of university strategies and practices aimed at achieving the best results in training, research and services through maintaining diversity and inclusive processes. The world's leading universities are actively involved in the process of creating an inclusive friendly environment and services, which are accessible to all members of the educational process, regardless of their social status and development characteristics. When universities reach academic heights, they recognise inclusion as the next level of their development. In turn, inclusion becomes a factor in the movement of the university towards academic excellence. The key characteristics and contradictions of the convergence of the concepts of inclusive and academic excellence of universities are identified. The local models of inclusive excellence of universities and the contexts, which influence these models, are described. The gaps between educational policies and research agendas of leading universities are revealed. The clusters of international studies on inclusive processes in higher education are highlighted.

Practical significance. Russian universities, which implement the federal programme for improvement of international competitiveness based on the values of academic excellence, are developing in accordance with global trends. Therefore, the model of inclusive excellence of the university can be used in practical terms to implement inclusive strategies and overcome social inequality both at the university and outside of it within the framework of a new educational initiative of Russia on academic leadership.

1. Kant I. Metafizika nravov = The metaphysics of morals. In 6 volumes. Vol. 4. Part. 2. Moscow, 1965. p. 386-388. (In Russ.)

2. Jahanbegloo R. The pursuit of excellence and the role of philosophy. Co-herencia. 2014; 10: 179-186. DOI: 10.17230/co-herencia.11.20.9

3. Liu Z., Moshi G. J., Awuor C. M. Sustainability and Indicators of Newly Formed World-Class Universities (NFWCUs) between 2010 and 2018: Empirical analysis from the rankings of ARWU, QSWUR and THEWUR. Sustainability. 2019; 11: 2745.

4. Salmi D., Froumin I. Russian universities in the world competition. Voprosy obrazovaniya = Educational Studies Moscow. 2007; 3: 5-45. (In Russ.)

5. Altbach P. G., Salmi D. Doroga a akademicheskomu sovershenstvu. Stanovlenie is-sledovatel'skih universitetov mirovogo klassa = The road to academic excellence: The making of world-class research universities. Moscow: Publishing House Ves' mir; 2012. 362 p. (In Russ.)

6. Antonova N. L., Sushchenko A. D., Popova N. G. Soft power of higher education as a global leadership factor. Obrazovanie i nauka = The Education and Science Journal. 2020; 22 (1): 31-58. DOI: https://doi.org/10.17853/1994-5639-2020-1-31-58 (In Russ.)

7. Ouda H., Khadri A. Strategic approach for developing world-class universities in Egypt. Journal of Education and Practice. 2015; 6 (5): 125-145.

8. Hazelkorn E. Rankings and the reshaping of higher education: The battle for worldclass excellence [Internet]. 2nd ed. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan; 2015. 304 p.

9. Spence M. Sledujushhaja konvergencija: budushhee jekonomicheskogo rosta v mire, zhivushhem na raznyh skorostjah = The next convergence: The future of economic growth in a multispeed world. Moscow: The Gaidar Institute Publishing House; 2013. 336 p. (In Russ.)

10. Clayton-Pedersen A. R., Musil C. M. Making excellence inclusive. A framework for embedding diversity and inclusion into colleges and universities' academic excellence mission [Internet]. Washington, DC: AAC&U; 2009 [cited 2020 May 27]. Available from: https://www.aacu.org/sites/default/files/files/mei/MEI.pdf

11. Considine J. R., Mihalick J. E., Mogi-Hein Y. R., Penick-Parks M. W., Van Auken P. M. How do you achieve inclusive excellence in the classroom? Teaching and Learning. 2017: 151; 171-187. DOI: 10.1002/tl.20255

12. Kwak N., Gavrila S., Ramirez F. O. Enacting diversity in American higher education. In: Christensen T., Gornitzka A., Ramirez F. (eds). Universities as agencies. Public sector organizations. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan; 2019. p. 209-228.

13. Readings B. Universitet v ruinah = The university in ruins. Moscow: Publishing House Higher School of Economics; 2010. 304 p. (In Russ.)

14. Derrida J. The university through the eyes of its pets. Otechestvennye zapiski = Annals of the Fatherland [Internet]. 2003 [cited 2020 May 27]; 6 (15). Available from: http://www.strana-oz.ru/?numid=15&article=723 (In Russ.)

15. Lyotard J.-F. Sostojanie postmoderna = The postmodern condition. Moscow; St. Petersburg: Institute of Experimental Sociology; Aleteia; 1998. 160 p. (In Russ.)

16. Pokrovsky N. E. By-product of civilization: Universities in the face of radical change. Obshhestvennye nauki i sovremennost' = Social Sciences and Contemporary World. 2005; 4: 148-154. (In Russ.)

17. Kurennoy V. Philosophy of liberal education: The contexts. Voprosy obrazovaniya = Educational Studies Moscow. 2020; 2: 8-36. DOI: 10.17323/1814-9545-2020-2-8-36 (In Russ.)

18. Boguslavsky M. V., Neborsky E. V., Neborskaya V. V., Syutkina I. S., Yushkova L. A.. Vysshee obrazovanie v nemeckoj i russkoj tradicijah = Higher education in German and Russian traditions. Izhevsk: Institute of Computer Research; 2016. 284 p. (In Russ.)

19. Emelyanova I. N., Volosnikova L. M. Functions of modern universities: Comparative analysis of missions of international and national institutions. Universitetskoe upravlenie: prak-tika i analiz = University Management: Practice and Analysis. 2018; 22 (1): 83-92. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15826/umpa.2018.01.008 (In Russ.)

20. Kolesnikov A. S. Humanities and the university of the postmodern era. Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta. Filosofija. Konfliktologija = Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Philosophy and Conflict Studies [Internet]. 2015 [cited 2020 May 27]; 31 (4): 41-47. Available from: https://philosophyjournal.spbu.ru/article/view/2784 (In Russ.)

21. Bleiklie I. Organizing higher education in a knowledge society. Higher Education. 2005; 49: 31-59. DOI: 10.1007/s10734-004-2913-7

22. Hernandez-Torrano D., Somerton M., Helmer J. Mapping research on inclusive education since the Salamanca Statement: A bibliometric review of the literature over 25 years. International Journal of Inclusive Education. 2020. DOI: 10.1080/13603116.2020.1747555

23. Mieghem A. V., Verschueren K., Petry K., Struyf E. An analysis of research on inclusive education: A systematic search and meta review. International Journal of Inclusive Education. 2020; 24 (6): 675-689. DOI: 10.1080/13603116.2018.1482012

24. Lombardi A., Gelbar N., Dukes LL III, Kowitt J., Wei Y., Madaus J., Lalor A. R., Faggella-Luby M. Higher education and disability: A systematic review of assessment instruments designed for students, faculty, and staff. Journal of Diversity in Higher Education. 2018; 11 (1): 34-50. DOI: 10.1037/dhe0000027

25. Brown R. Higher education and inequality. Perspectives: Policy and Practice in Higher Education. 2018; 22 (2): 37-43. DOI: 10.1080/13603108.2017.1375442

26. Bailey K. A. Racism within the Canadian university: Indigenous students' experiences. Ethnic and Racial Studies. 2016; 39 (7): 1261-1279.

27. Corkum T. Where is queer? Migration experiences of sexual minority international students in Toronto. University of Toronto; 2015. 126 p.

28. Michalski J. H., Cunningham T., Henry J. The diversity challenge for higher education in Canada: The prospects and challenges of increased access and student success. Humboldt Journal of Social Relations. 2017; 39: 66-89.

29. Alon S. The evolution of class inequality in higher education: Competition, exclusion, and adaptation. American Sociological Review. 2009; 74 (5): 731-755. DOI: 10.1177/000312240907400503

30. Gautreaux M. Towards shared understandings: An exploration of the literature on inclusive teaching and its implication for building Inclusive Excellence at UBC [Internet]. UBC: Sustainability Scholar; 2018 [cited 2020 May 27]. Available from: https://sustain.ubc.ca/sites/default/files/2018-36%20Inclusive%20teaching%20and%20its%20implication%20for%20building%20Inclusive%20Excellence%20at%20UBC.pdf

31. Volosnikova L. M., Fedina L. V., Kukuev E. A., Patrusheva I. V., Ogorodnova O. V. Academic mobility for everyone: Between vision and reality. Psihologo-pedagogicheskie issledovanija = Psychological-Educational Studies. 2019; 11 (3), 26-43. DOI: 10.17759/psye-du.2019110303 (In Russ.)

32. Litvinova V. Yu. Methodology for developing content analysis techniques and its application in pedagogical diagnostics. Izvestija Juzhnogo federal'nogo universiteta = Proceedings of Southern Federal University. 2006; 9 (2): 131-134. (In Russ.)

33. Waltman L., van Eck N. Jan, Noyons E. C. M. A unified approach to mapping and clustering of bibliometric networks. Journal of Informetrics. 2010; 4 (4): 629-635.

34. Faust D. G. The role of the university in a changing world [Internet]. 2010 [cited 2020 May 27]. Available from: https://www.harvard.edu/president/speech/2010/role-university-chang-ing-world

35. Higbee J. L., Gof E. Pedagogy and student services for institutional transformation: Implementing universal design in higher education. Center for Research on Developmental Education and Urban Literacy (CRDEUL). University of Minnesota General College; 2008. 496 р.

36. Van Eck N. J., Waltman L. Visualizing bibliometric networks. In: Y. Ding, R. Rousseau, D. Wolfram (eds.). Measuring scholarly impact: Methods and practice. Springer International Publishing; 2014. p. 285-320.

37. Morina A., Morgado B. University surroundings and infrastructures that are accessible and inclusive for all: Listening to students with disabilities. Journal of Further and Higher Education. 2018; 42 (1): 13-23. DOI: 10.1080/0309877X.2016.1188900

38. Gibson S. When rights are not enough: What is? Moving towards new pedagogy for inclusive education within UK universities. International Journal of Inclusive Education. 2015; 19 (8): 875-886. DOI: 10.1080/13603116.2015.1015177

39. Zundans-Fraser L., Bain A. The role of collaboration in a comprehensive programme design process in inclusive education. International Journal of Inclusive Education. 2016; 20 (2): 136-148. DOI: 10.1080/13603116.2015.1075610

40. Bronkema R. H., Bowman N. A. Close campus friendships and college student success. Journal of College Student Retention: Research, Theory & Practice. 2019; 21 (3): 270-285. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1521025117704200

41. Kantor V. Z., Proekt Y. L. Inclusive higher education: Socio-psychological well-being of students. Obrazovanie i nauka = The Education and Science Journal. 2019; 21 (2): 51-73. DOI: https://doi.org/10.17853/1994-5639-2019-2-51-73 (In Russ.)

42. Morina A., Carnerero F. Conceptions of disability at education: A systematic review. International Journal of Disability, Development and Education. 2020. DOI: 10.1080/1034912X.2020.1749239

43. Barra Cr., Maietta O. W., ZottiR. Academic excellence, local knowledge spillovers and innovation in Europe. Regional Studies. 2019; 53 (7): 1058-1069. DOI:10.1080/00343404.2018.1540865

44. D'EsteP., Tang P., MahdiS., Neely A., Sanchez-Barrioluengo M. The pursuit of academic excellence and business engagement: is it irreconcilable? Scientometrics. 2013; 95: 481-502. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-013-0955-2

45. Mampaey J. Are higher education institutions trapped in conformity? A translation perspective. Studies in Higher Education. 2018; 43 (7): 1241-1253. DOI: 10.1080/03075079.2016.1242566

46. Razack S., Hodges B., Steinert Y., Maguire M. Seeking inclusion in an exclusive process: Discourses of medical school student selection. Medical Education. 2015; 49 (1): 36-47. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/medu.12547

47. Yogev A. The stratification of Israeli universities: Implications for higher education policy. Higher Education [Internet]. 2000 [cited 2020 May 29]; 40 (2): 183-201. Available from: www.jstor.org/stable/3448109

48. Hardy I., Woodcock S. Inclusive education policies: Discourses of difference, diversity and deficit. International Journal of Inclusive Education. 2015; 19 (2): 141-164. DOI: 10.1080/13603116.2014.908965

49. Dias D. Has massification of higher education led to more equity? Clues to a reflection on Portuguese education arena. International Journal of Inclusive Education. 2015; 19 (2): 103-120. DOI: 10.1080/13603116.2013.788221

50. Garrett P., Gallego-Balsa L. International universities and implications of internationalisation for minority languages: Views from university students in Catalonia and Wales. Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development. 2014; 35 (4): 361-375. DOI: 10.1080/01434632.2013.874434

51. Leung W. H. M. Social mobility via academic mobility: Reconfigurations in class and gender identities among Asian scholars in the global north. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies. 2017; 43 (16): 2704-2719. DOI: 10.1080/1369183X.2017.1314595

52. Makoelle T., Kioko V. Inclusivity: An exploratory study into learning and teaching experiences of disabled students at Winchester University. International Education Studies. 2014; 7 (6): 106-116.

53. Peters S. J., Engerrand K. G. Equity and excellence: Proactive efforts in the identification of underrepresented students for gifted and talented services. Gifted Child Quarterly. 2016; 60 (3): 159-171. DOI: 10.1177/0016986216643165

54. Sternberg R. J. Increasing academic excellence and enhancing diversity are compatible goals. Educational Policy. 2008; 22 (4): 487-514. DOI: 10.1177/0895904807310037

55. Lawrie G., Marquis E., Fuller E., Newman T., Qui M., Nomikoudis M., Roelofs F., van Dam L. Moving towards inclusive learning and teaching: A synthesis of recent literature. Teaching & Learning Inquiry. 2017; 5 (1). DOI: 10.20343/teachlearninqu.5.1.3

56. Mercer-Mapstone L., Dvorakova S. L., Matthews K., Abbot S., Cheng B., Felten P., Knorr K., Marquis E., Shammas R., Swaim K. A systematic literature review of students as partners in higher education. International Journal for Students as Partners. 2017; 1 (1). DOI: 10.15173/ijsap.v1i1.3119

57. O'Shea S. Equity and students as partners: The importance of inclusive relationships. International Journal for Students as Partners. 2018; 2 (2): 16-20. DOI: 10.15173/ijsap.v2i2.3628

58. Hattke F., Blaschke S. Striving for excellence: The role of top management team diversity in universities. Team Performance Management. 2015; 21 (3/4): 121-138. DOI: 10.1108/TPM-03-2014-0019

59. Kim S., Canfield J., Desrosiers P., Harley D., Hunn V. Embracing inclusive excellence: Asian and Asian American college students. Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment. 2019; 29 (8): 1015-1025. DOI: 10.1080/10911359.2019.1647907